top of page

Forum Comments

Oil type
In General Discussion
Robert Slifkin
Dec 23, 2024
15W-40 diesel oil (or 5W-40 if you use the boat a lot in cold weather) would be my first choice for a marine big block. It's not the highest zinc oil out there, but it's got plenty for the relatively mild cams in stock flat tappet engines. My 454s have been running on either Rotella or Delo 15W-40 for years, originally the conventional version, then they got switched to synthetic blend because at some point it became cheaper and easier to find. Many of the diesel oils are dual rated for use in gas engines (the most current ratings would be CK-4 / SN) and pretty much any of them are good performing oils, so within the realm of diesel oils, I'd just get what's easy to find and at a good price and use it. An xxW-40 is a suitable viscosity range for a 454 and there's no reason why a marine 454 is overly hard on oil, so realistically, anything in that viscosity range and with an appropriate amount of ZDDP for the flat tappet cam will do fine. If you want to know more than you ever dreamed about oil, do some searching on bobistheoilguy.com, there are people there that have done analysis on tons of different oils in different engines, etc. and a few actual oil chemists on the site as well. With modern oils, outside of certain applications with very specific needs (like 2 stroke Detroits), there is no good reason to run a straight weight oil. The issues with multigrades shearing badly, etc. that people worried about 50 years ago aren't really a concern now in most cases.
0
0
1984 CC Commander 315 MIE 340 engine rotation question.
In General Discussion
1968 38 ft commander Starboard motor running hot self contained.
In General Discussion
OEM Parts vs. Aftermarket
In General Discussion
Robert Slifkin
Mar 05, 2024
Personally, I rarely end up using OEM fluids and filters, but instead determine what I think will be most suitable for my application. For example, Mercruiser recommends straight 40 weight oil for my 454s. With modern oils, there's no reason for that, it's just an invitation for more startup wear and a harder to find oil. So instead, my engines get 15W-40 diesel oil (typically Delo or Rotella), which is perfectly suitable for their needs, easier to find, flows better at startup (especially in cool spring or fall weather), etc. And while many OEM oil filters are good, there's nothing magic about them compared to any good quality aftermarket filter. So for each engine, I typically pick a filter that's good quality and readily available and stick to that. For my engines, it's mostly been Wix filters as the options I'd like better (Fram Ultra or Purolator PureOne or Boss) don't produce a compatible filter (Purolator and Fram only produce the correct filter in their lower end lines that I don't want to use). For parts, I'll sometimes go OEM, sometimes not. Unless I'm in a rush and need something right away, I tend to do some analysis on quality and determine if there's a more suitable option than OEM, or if there's something equivalent in quality to OEM but cheaper. When buying BMW parts, I've found cases where there's an aftermarket version made by the same company that makes the OE BMW part. And the only difference between them is the price tag (about 50%) and having the BMW logo ground off when the part comes out of the mold (for the ones they sell directly instead of sending to BMW). Other times, there is no good quality aftermarket alternative or there's not enough information out there, so the OEM part is the best choice. For belts, I tend to go to Gates or Continental, as I know they reliably make good belts, and the appropriate belt from either tends to be far cheaper than the OEM belts of unknown origin. Hoses are selected from any good hose supplier based on what hose is suitable for the application. The only time I'll spend the extra on an OEM hose is if there's something unique about it (such as a molded shape that's truly necessary for proper fit) that isn't available from an aftermarket supplier. Generally I buy hose from Gates, Continental, Trident, or Shields. Of course, there's always the struggle for what the best option is when the OEM part is discontinued (such as the impellers for my Onan generator). In the case of that generator, there are 2 aftermarket impellers available. I've tried one and it was junk that broke apart just past the 1 year mark. I have yet to try the other, but I'm on my last NOS OEM impeller, so I might have to. Or, I may convert the unit to a different seawater pump setup to get away from the problem.
0
0
Impeller Schedules
In General Discussion
Robert Slifkin
Feb 20, 2024
I change mine every 2 years before the start of the season. If we were putting a ton of hours on the boat and boating year round, I'd probably change at 300 hours and assess condition to determine if I should go longer. At the 2 year mark (and after 2 winters soaking in antifreeze) the impellers are usually intact, not cracked or worn, but starting to get a bit stiff (which can cause issues with failing to prime if they suck any air). I figure if they're always in good condition when I change them, my schedule is appropriate and I should have a very low chance of needing to do an un-planned change (which is good, as the Merc pumps would be a pain to remove and open up on a hot engine). Rubber and fiberglass exhaust parts will melt down fast with a loss of water flow, especially if the engine is under any significant load. If there's an easy way to add it on your setup, a water flow or exhaust temperature alarm is a good idea. My generator has an exhaust temp sensor in the safety shutdown circuit, but I have not added exhaust temp alarms to the engines. However, my exhausts have 2 stage water lift mufflers, so in terms of noise, it's extremely obvious if water flow becomes significantly restricted or disappears. Personally, the only sudden impeller failures I've seen (on any engine or generator) have been on startup. While running I've seen loss of water flow happen due to sucking junk against the intake or other issues, but I haven't seen an impeller just come apart while it's pumping water.
0
0

Robert Slifkin

More actions
bottom of page